Order by December 15th at noon for arrival before Christmas

Buttermilk <em>Pie</em> - Southern Baked Pie Company Buttermilk <em>Pie</em> - Southern Baked Pie Company Buttermilk <em>Pie</em> - Southern Baked Pie Company
Buttermilk <em>Pie</em> - Southern Baked Pie Company

Order Deadlines:

  • November 17th at noon for arrival by Thanksgiving
  • December 20th at noon for arrival by Christmas

Amanda’s mother in law’s heirloom recipe that started it all! A velvety custard pie, baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg, in our signature, handmade all-butter crust. For holidays, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. 

 Pies are 10 inches in diameter and serve 8 - 10 slices. 

If you wish to purchase more than 12 pies at a once, we request you call our office at 404.263.0656 ext. 1 so that we can personally assist you with your order. 

Ingredients - butter, sugar, egg, flour, buttermilk, vanilla, nutmeg, salt


Shipping Details

Pies are shipped Monday-Wednesday. Pies will arrive within 1-3 business days. Shipping is costly because food products are expedited and perishable. Pies are carefully packaged and shipped frozen with ice packs in insulated coolers. Sweet pies will arrive cool to the touch. IMPORTANT: Please use the calendar on the CART page to select the day you would like your pie TO SHIP before selecting CHECKOUT. If you would like expedited shipping, please contact our office directly at 404.263.0656 ext 4 for pricing and options.

Storage & Reheating instructions

Sweet pies arrive fully baked and are ready to cut and serve. If pies are still cold or frozen upon arrival, allow pies time to thaw on the counter - approximately 30 minutes. If you do not wish to serve immediately, place pies in the freezer for up to 6 months.


Follow along with baker and founder Amanda Wilbanks:

Customer Reviews