Secret_Pie_Teaser_May_2026_Peanut_butter_1000_x_1500_px

A Secret Pie is Dropping Soon… 

Our Secret Pie Drops are limited release flavors made for our most loyal pie fans. VIPie members get first access before anyone else.

Don’t Miss the Secret Drop

Set a reminder for Wednesday, May 27 at 12 PM ET. VIP access only, this pie won’t last long!

Add to Apple Calendar Add to Google Calendar

SECRET PIE IS HERE

SECRET PIE 

.

$0.00
- {price}%
Product may contain:

Milk, Wheat, Peanuts, Soy

Ready to Taste the Secret?

just fill out the form below and you'll be notified when it drops.
 One batch. Early access only. When it sells out, it is gone.
Why Our VIPie Members Get the Sweetest Slice
  • Early access to drops.
  • Exclusive deals
  • First dibs on limited quantities.

  • SBP-Oven_FFFFFF

    Frequently 
    Asked Questions

    S_moresSlice

    What is a secret pie drop?

    The Secret Pie is an exclusive, limited-release flavor that’s only available in small batches.

    How often are pies dropped?

    There’s no set schedule, Secret Pie Drops happen at random! Each release is a limited batch, so if you see one you love, don’t wait! The best way to stay in the know is to join the VIPie list for early access to every drop.

    How does the Secret Pie drop work?

    VIPiers get early access for 24 hours before we release it to the public. If you’re on the VIPie list, you’ll receive a secret link on drop day to order before it sells out.


    Can I buy the Secret Pie in stores?

    Yes! A limited number of pies will be available in stores while supplies last. However, ordering online guarantees you don’t miss out!