2026 Valentine's Gift Guide - Made with Love, Baked from the Heart

Valentine’s Day is all about sharing love - and what better way than with something made-from-scratch, heartfelt, and irresistibly delicious? Whether you're sending a sweet surprise to someone special, gathering with loved ones, or treating yourself to a little joy, our Valentine’s collection is full of warmth, comfort, and Southern charm.
From buttery heart-shaped pies to thoughtfully curated gift boxes, every bite is a reminder that the best gifts come from the heart - and taste like home.
Valentine's Day Gift Sets:
Gift Boxes so you can get more and save more!
Perfect to grab all your sweetheart's favorites in one box or to celebrate with an easy & romantic evening in!
Valentine's Dinner & Dessert BoxA cozy celebration in one beautiful box. Featuring a choice of savory dinner pie and your choice of a classic dessert pie, it’s everything you need for a romantic night in, a heartfelt gift, or a delicious way to say “I love you.” |
![]() |
Valentine's Day Gift BoxUnwrap the magic of love with our Valentine's Day Gift Box, a delectable duo that promises to sweeten your celebrations. Choose the pie that speaks to your heart -whether it's the festive Cherry Heart Pie or the irresistible Caramel Pecan - paired with a bag of our Gourmet Valentines Day Popcorn. Elevate your romantic moments with this delightful combination, a truly sweet way to say 'I love you' in every delicious bite. |
|
Grandparent Valentine's Gift BoxEmbrace the little things in life with the Grandparent's Valentines Gift Box. Includes two Petite Cherry Heart Pies, two savory Petite Chicken Pot Pies, and a bag of Gourmet Valentines Day Popcorn. This heartwarming ensemble is a delightful mix of sweet and savory, creating a perfect moment for shared joy and delicious memories. Celebrate their special bond with a gift that says 'I love you' in every delightful bite. |
|
Deluxe Valentine's Day Gift BoxIndulge in a symphony of flavors designed to captivate your senses, with our Deluxe Valentines Day Gift Box . Unbox delight with four petite sweet pies, perfectly complemented by four savory delights like the Chicken Pot Pie & Southwestern Taco. As the perfect pairing, enjoy two bags of our gourmet popcorn, adding a touch of crunch to your celebration. |
|
4 Pack Valentine's Day Cherry PieA perfect combination of tart and sweet, with special pie-crust hearts just in time for Valentine's Day! Cherry pie is bright and bursting with fresh sour cherries and crowned with an old-fashioned handmade lattice, all-butter crust. |
|
Gifts Under $25:
Southern Baked: Celebrating Life With Pie Cookbook
|
|
Gourmet PecansMammoth Pecans, locally grown in Georgia, two decadent ways - Chocolate Amaretto and Salted & Roasted. Perfect to set out for holiday guests, or keep in their bag for an on-the-go snack. |
|
Valentine's Day White Chocolate PopcornThis Valentine's Day, gift your special someone a bag of White Chocolate Popcorn! Gourmet popcorn covered in a decadent layer of white chocolate, tossed with pink and red sprinkles, milk chocolate m&ms, & pretzel sticks for the ultimate Valentine's Day Snack. |
![]() |
Southern Baked Pie Gift CardSend it electronically via an email for any increment, or pick one up from your local pie shop. |
![]() |
Petite Cherry Heart PieIn-Store Exclusive A 5" individual pie in both sweet and savory flavors, gift them their favorite pie - no sharing required. |
![]() |
Cherry Heart HandpiesIn-Store Exclusive The Perfect Portable Pie - great for your child's Valentine's exchange, teacher gifts, or a sweet treat for yourself! |
Gifts Under $50:
A Signature Southern Baked Pie
|
![]() |
The Pie PurseNeeding a gift for the one who's always running around, traveling, or always brings snacks to the game? This stylish, easy to clean, and TSA-Friendly bag makes the perfect hostess gift to stuff with their favorite goodies and pie! P.S. It can hold up to 4 bottles of wine too. |
![]() |
Southern Baked Pie X Heirloomed Candle
|
![]() |
Southern Baked Pie Gift CardSend it electronically via an email for any increment, or pick one up from your local pie shop. |
![]() |
4-Pack Petite Pie BoxFeatured in O Magazine for Oprah's Favorite things: a variety pack of 5" individual pies in either sweet or savory flavors. Gift them convenience and minis to share...or not. |
![]() |
As you embark on the festive gifting journey this loving season, remember that the joy of giving is as sweet as the pies we offer. Whether it's a cozy breakfast with Old-Fashioned Cinnamon Rolls, or having a romantic dinner at home, our collection is designed to elevate your gifting game and give the gift of time to create cherished moments that linger to keep the romance going.













